Recollections and reflections

Reminiscences, Rafi Ahmad Kidwai

I first came in contact with Subhas Bose in 1923 at Delhi when the Congress was divided into two groups over the question of what was known as 'Council Entry.'...Subhas Babu, as the favourite lieutenant of Deshabandhu, was playing a prominent part in the controversy. more>>

What is the true identity of the monk in the picture?

dhammavira

By Anuj Dhar

Good heavens! Is it a ghostly apparition or what? What was a man long dead doing by the side of his recently deceased friend?

No other snippet of the Netaji mystery has traversed generational gaps like this one. They say that for old time's sake Subhas Bose had turned up to pay respects to Jawaharlal Nehru's body in New Delhi's Teen Murti Bhavan in May 1964. Well, about time Mission Netaji swiftly busted the long-standing myth that provoked critics to bracket the disbelievers in the Taipei plane crash theory with the crackpots who encountered Elvis Presley, the late King of the Rock.

The monk seen in the above image, taken from a movie reel, could not be Bose for he was Vira Dhammavara -- a venerable Cambodian Buddhist monk who lived in south Delhi for decades before passing away in the US only a couple of years back at the grand old age of 110. Dhammavara's inadvertent doppelganger act lasted barely for a second on camera, but it triggered a sensation so strong that it caused commotion in India for several years. How did the monk take it? Disciples say he was much amused.

Likeness aside, Dhammavara was short statured unlike Netaji, who, in case you did not know, was almost 5' 10". 

Take a closer look ...

dhammvira

And if you still won't take our word, check out this montage.

montage

Now, if such a scenario could be replicated in Italy, what would the researchers there had done? I am sure they would have at least not behaved in so wimpish a manner like the lot in India did from 1950s onward as they added to the mess of mystery. The only instances of research into Bose's fate were attempts by a handful of individuals in their personal capacities. For the establishment, and those who gained from it, the matter was closed in the 1950s itself even as secret official reports keep coming in doubting the air crash theory. The government was forced by handful of Bose admirers to enact facades of inquiries that arrived at pre-determined conclusions.

It was only recently that the truth finally triumphed as a commission of inquiry appointed on court orders shot down the air crash theory and gave solid reasons to believe in the Russian angle. But then, the establishment went against it and rejected the commission's inquiry citing reasons that would not stand in any court of law, provided there are good lawyers are around and cynicism isn't. 

Maybe one can hazard a guess as to why the ambassador's tenor reeked of prejudices that can so clearly be attributed to some motivated individuals. For all we know, he was inspired by the world view of the organizers of his lecture -- the government-backed Netaji Research Bureau of former Congress party MP Krishna Bose and her Harvard Don son Sugata Bose. Mrs Bose is the wife of late Sisir Kumar Bose, Netaji's nephew who used to be a Congress party MLA. Some uncharitable things have been said about this section of the family. Suffice it would be to say that despite their influence, they represent only a small section of the Bose family that continues to hold the view that the truth about Subhas Chandra Bose's death must be settled in the national interest.

Read Online

Free Indian Legion

Free Indian Legion

India's number one news channel Times Now investigates the mystery of disappearance of Subhas Chandra Bose. Subhas Chandra Bose may have secretly lived in India for decades after his supposed death.

Indian National Army

Free Indian Legion

After more than 60 years, many issues regarding the Indian National Army remain hotly debated, with government attitude ranging from subtly hostile, indifferent, and occasional platitudes..

Chronological List Of INA Events

Copyright Information

We believe that all of Netaji's works are national property, and information on him should be easily available at the lowest cost, if not for free. You are free to use any material from this site with proper acknowledgement. At the same time, we respect the copyright of authors of original works and would not intentionally violate their copyright or any part of the Indian Copyright Act. If you think you have noticed any infringement, please do let us know.